Episode Guide / Opinion / Pilot

Episode review: Columbo Ransom for a Dead Man


It’s been some time coming, but my bid to review all of Columbo’s 69 episodes is back on track. If you haven’t already done so, you can read my thoughts on 1968’s seminal Prescription: Murder here.

This time round we’re stepping back to 1st March, 1971, to revisit the second ever Columbo episode (and first official pilot), Ransom for a Dead Man. So buckle up and let’s fly with Peter Falk and Lee Grant…

Ransom for a Dead Man blog

Dramatis personae

Lieutenant Columbo: Peter Falk
Leslie Williams: Lee Grant
Margaret Williams: Patricia Mattick
Agent Carlson: Harold Gould
Directed by: Richard Irving
Score by: Billy Goldenberg
Written by: Dean Hargrove (from a story by Richard Levinson and William Link)

Episode synopsis – Columbo Ransom for a Dead Man

Ace lawyer Leslie Williams has no further use for elderly husband, Paul, so she shoots him, and disposes of the body in the ocean. A wily one, Leslie has a perfect plan to side-step suspicion. Using answer machine tape audio of her husband (the first example of what would become a Columbo staple), and by fashioning a ransom note saying he’s been kidnapped, she puts her elaborate scheme into action.

Ransom gunshot

Stylish visuals are a hallmark of the episode

The FBI is called in, in the suave shape of Agent Carlson. The LAPD representative is his polar opposite: the scruffy Lieutenant Columbo, who appears in bumbling fashion having lost his pen in the dark doorway of the house. But while the FBI go through the motions, ignoring Columbo, it is the Lieutenant who starts asking questions. As an automated phone call comes in to her home, playing the message Leslie created to make her husband appear to be alive and well, and demanding a $300,000 ransom, it’s only Columbo that notices that she didn’t ask if he’s alright. That bothers him, and it’s the first sign of the cogs in his razor-sharp mind whirring into action.

Once she has the ransom cash, what follows is an intricate set piece where Leslie, a skilled pilot, heads out in her light aircraft to a pre-arranged drop point over the desert. There she flings an empty bag out of the plane window, supposedly containing the ransom money, which she had already nabbed. As Leslie circles back to the airstrip, the FBI and police storm the drop site to find just the empty bag.

Again, only Columbo wonders why the kidnappers bothered to leave the bag behind instead of making an instant getaway. He even picks the lock of Leslie’s locker in the airport’s pilot room, but she’s already removed the evidence and stashed it in a secret compartment in her walk-in wardrobe.

“Lieutenant Columbo appears in bumbling fashion having lost his pen in the dark doorway of the house.”

The next day, the body of Leslie’s husband is discovered. The news is broken to her in court prior to trial and, for the first time, she breaks down, collapsing in front of witnesses and has to be escorted out. Again, Columbo is bothered. Why lose it now when she’s been so calm and collected? Why didn’t she ask where the body was found, or how he died?

Columbo’s suspicions aside, things have gone to plan for Leslie. All until Margaret – her husband’s daughter – returns home from Switzerland, that is, to act as the thorn in her side. The two despise each other and Margaret makes a scene at the funeral, slapping Leslie’s face and bellowing: “This what you wanted, isn’t it?” Columbo comforts Margaret at the cemetery. He has found a likely ally in his bid to prove Leslie’s guilt.

As the episode races to its conclusion, via a wonderful scene where Leslie takes the Lieutenant on a spin in her plane (much to his discomfort), it is the relationship he has forged with Margaret that gives Columbo the edge. Over a bowl of chilli at his favourite diner, Margaret reveals to Columbo that Leslie hated her father, and had used his reputation in the legal profession to springboard her own ambitions. Margaret is sure Leslie pulled the trigger, but there’s still no hard evidence. So they cook up a scheme of their own as fiendishly clever as Leslie’s was.

Ransom for a Dead Man flight

The scene where Leslie takes Columbo for an airborne spin is a memorable set-piece

In full-on psycho mode, Margaret terrorises Leslie in her own home, firing blanks from a gun at her, and letting her know that she knows the ransom bags were switched. Margaret will get out of Leslie’s hair and back to Europe, she says, if Leslie will pay her her $25,000 annual allowance. Leslie takes the bait.

After an icy farewell at the airport with Margaret, Leslie runs into, who else, but Lieutenant Columbo. He invites her to have a drink: his tone suggesting it’s a farewell knowing she’s beaten him fair and square. Then the coup de grace: Columbo produces the ransom money that Leslie had used to pay off Margaret. Only the killer could have the money. Ultimately, it’s Leslie’s greed, and total lack of conscience that has done her in.

As Columbo puts it himself: “Mrs. Williams, you have no conscience and that’s your weakness. Did it ever occur to you that there are very few people who would take money to forget about a murder? It didn’t, did it? I knew it wouldn’t.”

Another officer escorts Leslie down town, and Columbo is left with a bill for the drinks he can’t pay, despite having $25k on the table in front of him, as credits roll…

Ransom for a Dead Man finale

Money, money everywhere, but not a cent to spend: Columbo can’t pay the drinks bill despite $25k in cash in his hands

Best moment – the quiet ‘f*** you!’

It’s a bit of an under-the-radar moment, but the scene in the courtroom following the revelation that Leslie’s husband’s body has been found, where the Lieutenant asserts his authority over the smarmy Agent Carlson, is a moment to treasure.

When Columbo starts discussing all the things that bother him about Leslie’s reaction, Carlson gets snooty. “Let’s understand this one thing,” he bleats. “If you start harassing this woman I’m going to take it upstairs.”

Cue a magnificent Columbo comeback: “Um, just one minute, Mr. Carlson. It’s like this. This is not just a kidnapping. This is a murder now and I kinda figure that’s my department. I’ll see ya around.”

The message is clear: Columbo may be small. He may be scruffy. He may be humble. But he will not be pushed around.

Carlson vs Columbo

Suave FBI man Carlson is ultimately demoted to a support act by a steely Columbo once murder has been confirmed

My thoughts on Ransom for a Dead Man

What a difference three years makes! If you’ve read my review of Prescription: Murder, you’ll know that, while I loved the episode, I lamented that the Columbo we encounter in it is one we couldn’t love. As the ‘official’ pilot episode, the Ransom for a Dead Man Lieutenant Columbo had to be a character the audience could really dig. And, boy did they nail it.

Peter Falk might not have 100% mastered the character, but he’s pretty close. It’s a terrific performance, a big step up from Prescription, full of warmth and packed with the idiosyncracies that will come to define the character. Take the scene early on, when Columbo is discussing how Leslie’s fruit-shaped soaps stick together when wet, for example. It’s the classic Columbo disarming technique in action. Falk was in the groove straight away.

Equally importantly Lee Grant (a good friend of Falk’s) excels as Leslie Williams. Indeed, she would earn an Emmy nomination for her turn here. She’s wickedly cold, yet dangerously alluring at the same time (witness her flirtatiousness with Agent Carlson); a confident woman in a man’s world who isn’t afraid of anyone or anything. She takes calculated risks to achieve her outcomes, both professionally in court, recreationally in the air, and personally in murdering her ageing husband, and, ultimately, in paying off Margaret.

Ransom for a Dead Man

Columbo and Leslie Williams are evenly matched throughout the episode

And Leslie’s a very smart cookie – smart enough to recognise that Columbo is putting on an act, or, in her words employing his ‘shopworn bag of tricks’ that he uses to put suspects off their guard. She thinks she’s cleverer than him, naturally, but to give her credit she doesn’t underestimate him like so many others will in years to come: “Lieutenant Columbo, fumbling and stumbling along but it’s always the jugular that he’s after,” she notes. “And I imagine that more often than not he’s successful.” She certainly got that right…

And how about the episode itself? Well, in many ways it’s a big step up from Prescription: Murder. That one was an adaptation of a stage show, and it sometimes felt constrained by that. Not this time. Ransom for a Dead Man was an original story, and a big budget piece with few limits. They ramped everything up to 11, the sets, costumes, fashions – even the aerial footage of Leslie’s light aircraft. It has style and class in abundance.

“Billy Goldenberg’s score is a cinematic wonder – as good as anything gracing the silver screens of the time.”

Ransom captures that sense of ‘how the other half live’ as well as we ever see in the show’s long lifespan. It’s a visual treat, and would be great to see on a big screen to really gain maximum enjoyment from. Some of the editing techniques and fades are very 70s, but enhance the episode’s charm rather than detract.

Special praise must also go to Billy Goldenberg’s score. It’s a cinematic wonder, as good as anything gracing the silver screens of the time. He created an iconic theme, and then created variations on it, sometimes subtle, sometimes haunting, sometimes sweeping and orchestral. Heck, there’s even a muzak version at the airport. It’s great stuff and sets a standard that was perhaps equalled, but never bettered. Revel in its majesty in the clip below.

So if that’s all good, what didn’t work? Well, the uber-catty Margaret / Leslie relationship seems a bit too pantomime to believe at times. In fact Margaret as a whole is quite hard to stomach. I get that she’s the wronged party, but a lot of the time I just wanted her to pipe down and get off screen. Compared to the performances of Falk and Grant, Patricia Mattick’s turn as Margaret grates, and takes some of the gloss off the episode.

Some critics have savaged the ending, too, citing that someone as intelligent as Leslie would never be caught out the way she is. I don’t agree. As I alluded to above, I see Leslie as a risk taker. She calculates her odds in everything she does, and this is another example of that. Her actions are believable for her character.

“Ransom is technically superior to Prescription: Murder, yet oddly less enjoyable.”

The issue I do have with the ending is that it’s all over in such a hurry. Ransom is long for a Columbo episode, with a 98-minute running time. They had ages to play with, yet the final wrap-up in the airport is gone in a flash. This is a shame, as it gives the viewer little opportunity to savour the gotcha, or marvel at Columbo’s stunning victory.

As a result of these imperfections Ransom is, perhaps, a little less than the sum of its parts. It’s technically superior to Prescription: Murder, yet oddly less enjoyable. But credit to director Richard Irving, editor Edward Abroms and art director John Lloyd. They set out their stall to impress, and they did. The episode was a ratings hit and a critical success. A month after Ransom debuted, NBC commissioned a full series. Six months later, Season 1 would air.

So while Ransom might not ultimately be one of my absolute personal favourites, it has many merits, and did its job sufficiently well to pave the way for greater things to come. Murder by the Book is one such example. The first episode of Season 1 will be the next episode under review – and I’m already looking forward to it immensely.

Did you know?

Ransom for a Dead Man was released in cinemas around Europe, notably in the UK (in 1973) and Italy (in 1978). A magnificent series of film posters was produced for the Italian release (Riscatto per un uomo morto), which can sometimes be found on eBay and are well worth tracking down if you’re a collector. My own home has a good few of ’em.

Ransom for a Dead Man artwork

A series of very cool Italian movie posters for Ransom were produced

On a sadder note, Patricia Mattick, who played Margaret, died of cancer in December 2003, aged just 52. Ransom was just her second screen appearance.

Watch the episode closely and you can see that Margaret is watching the film Double Indemnity in the house kitchen during an argument with Leslie. Double Indemnity is about a woman who kills her husband to claim an insurance payout. Nice touch!

How I rate ’em so far

  1. Prescription: Murder
  2. Ransom for a Dead Man

Where does Ransom rank in your list of favourites? Vote for your number one episode in the Columbo best episode poll here.

Thanks, as ever, for reading. I’ll be back with a review of Murder by the Book soon.

Read my thoughts on the 5 best moments from Ransom for a Dead Man here.


Evil Leslie

See you next time…

How did you like this article?

117 thoughts on “Episode review: Columbo Ransom for a Dead Man

  1. Sorry, but this episode doesn’t work at all.
    Columbo doesn’t even invesigate here. He does do two things: he shows his aversion to flying in those pointless helicopter- and airplane-scenes and speaks about some circumstances bothering him. But he has no evidence whatsoever, He is hardly even involved in the story. The main characters are the villain and the stepdaughter. But she can’t prove her point either, so her action is limited to constantly repeating: “I know you did it ”
    The conclusion is even worse than that. For this sly lawyer who initially wanted to cut all her stepdaughter’s allowances would never ever give her the ransom money so that she wouldn’t fire dummy bullets at her.
    The theme was promising but the execution is just very poor.

    • Greetings! Ransom is on this Sunday 3/15 at 7 a m EST on Hallmark Movies and Mysteries- for me is the best episode. 👍💐👩🏻‍🦰👓 Ed

  2. ‪Greetings! Know Sunday is still far away but finally one of the networks will air Ransom for a Dead Man- they take their time to air it—-and is the best Columbo episode ever, in my humble opinion—Hallmark Movies & Mysteries is airing it next Sunday 3/15 @ 7 am EST- starring Peter Falk, Lee Grant & Patricia Mattick- March 15th-the ides of March. 👩🏻‍🦰👓💐📺🕵️‍♂️‬

    Ed from Florida

  3. Ransom for a dead man was aired last Sunday not one of my favorites but not a bad episode either , I find Margarets character was very annoying and the ending was a bit flat and predictable . best part/scene of this episode was the plane / Cessna scene ransom is ok but wouldn’t trouble my top 30 overall .

    • Margarets character was annoying. But do you think the actress purposely played her that way? You have a hard time mustering up any sympathy for her that’s for sure

    • Yesterday March 1st-49 years ago Ransom for a Dead Man aired on NBC…the 2nd pilot that convinced the network to launch the series ..starring Peter Falk, Lee Grant and a newcomer, an awesome 19 y/o redhead by the name of Patricia Mattick..the rest is history. RIP Patricia 🙏🏻👏📺

    • It’s true. Margaret was annoying. And Patricia was directed. She didn’t write the script or direct the episode. If the director had wanted her to be sweet (or even slightly less obnoxious), she could have played it that way. Patricia was so talented and professional, she could have played Margaret any way the director asked her to.

      I like how far out Margaret is. Her dad’s dead, Leslie’s a murderer, and Margaret knows it.

      Patricia enjoyed playing that part, and working with Peter Falk and Lee Grant.

    • Hello to all! Just FYI tomorrow Sunday 3/15 at 7 am EST- Hallmark Movies and Mysteries will air the 1971 classic, the 2nd pilot, “Ransom for a Dead Man”, starring Peter Falk, Lee Grant and Patricia Mattick. Let’s go back to March 1, 1971- I find it so interesting. Don’t remember the 70s much, was 2 y/o when Ransom premiered. Kudos to HMM, is the only network that shows it every now and then, no love from the others. Obviously I own the DVD – but love to watch it on TV. Despite what some people say, I love this episode, Patricia was so awesome.

      Ed from Florida 👍

  4. Easy to rank these 2 pilots

    1) Prescription Murder
    2) Ransom for a Dead man

    IN summary Ransom isnt a bad episode but Prescription murder is 5 times a more enjoyable quality and memorable outing and would almost make my top 10 overall.

    • Hello to all! Ed from Miami, FL. I’m the one always researching and writing about the late Patricia Mattick- Margaret in Ransom for a Dead Man. Is taking me longer than expected to her Wikipedia article up, boy, they are picky- but now she has an article on Everipedia- it has 22 views since this morning, if anyone cares to visit. She is also on Pinterest and Listal-under her name; below is the Everipedia link, or just type her name and it will come up. About time she had one! 👩🏻‍🦰Thank you for the opportunity to mention this, most awesome Columbophile!


      Ed, the Miami librarian 👍

  5. Pingback: Episode review: Columbo A Deadly State of Mind | THE COLUMBOPHILE

  6. Pingback: Episode review: Columbo Try & Catch Me | THE COLUMBOPHILE

  7. Watching it again, and thinking for the first time: did Leslie’s cover-up include sleeping with the FBI agent in charge of the investigation? She is especially charming to the poor guy. Then, after he kicks Columbo out of the house, Carlson doesn’t leave– and while I’m typing this, Margaret is sitting there watching Double Indemnity, where some dame knocks off her husband and has an affair with the insurance investigator. It’s a really faint hint…

  8. Just watched this episode again and saw a slight resemblance to the Grant and Falk airplane scene to the scene in the movie It’s A Mad Mad Mad Mad World, in which Mickey Rooney and Buddy Hackett were forced into landing a plane. Falk had a small cameo in that movie several years before this episode. I just wonder if the scene in this pilot episode was derived from that scene in this classic 1963 comedy.

  9. I’m watching this episode right now on COZI TV and find the music and direction pretty irritating. The stop-action business shown in the clip above when the shooting occurs is ridiculous, along with the accompanying smoke-detector music. I guess these silly effects were in vogue back then. Glad later episodes did not employ them.

    • Hello to all,

      Well done episode- great performances by Peter Falk and Lee Grant. Regarding Patricia Mattick- she was only 19 when the episode was filmed and her second acting opportunity- after Room 222, according to my researching. She did a fine job- a little unhinged, not bad. This is1971 and after all, her father was killed, not sure how I would have reacted if that happened to me. TV has changed so much- I saw this episode for the first time in the 80’s….when it came out I was 2 y/o….Awesome website- thank you for the opportunity of adding my 2 cents to the conversation.

      • Patricia Mattick tragically died of cancer in her 50s the early 2000s. Lee Grant (pushing 94 as of this writing) is the sole surviving credited actor from this episode, as far as I know, given that Falk and Gould are also long deceased.

        • Indeed, she died of cancer in FL in 2003 and was buried in her native Colorado. So only Lee Grant is alive-fine actress, a legend. RIP Patricia Mattick.
          Best regards,
          Ed, Columbo fan from FL

          • On behalf of my dear friend Patricia Mattick, I thank everyone for their continuing interest in her. She would be so pleased to know that she is remembered.

            • Thank you so much, Iva! 👌 I appreciate your comment so much, since you knew her. I never met Patricia but I seen most of her work that is available online or on DVD and she was a great actress- Tv, Theater, The Beguiled. Talented and soo beautiful.

              It saddens me she is not on this earth anymore but her work lives on, and it will always be remembered- every time they show Columbo’s Ransom on TV- my favorite episode. 👍
              I made a board on Pinterest and another one on Listal about her, and I am working on a Wikipedia article for her- she should have one. Hope this is ok, always respectful.
              Again, thank you for writing- this means a lot from someone that was her friend as you were.
              Best regards, Ed Porben 👋
              Miami, FL

            • Hello everyone! I just wanted to mention that I got on the mail the Ironside DVD of the episode “Walls are Waiting”- and it was an awesome episode. I know Columbo is dear to all our hearts as the best detective in the world…..but it was a great episode.
              Iva (Turner) if you read this- Patricia was amazing- such passion and how awesome the portrayed her character of Millie- scary and sad, in particular the end. She was so talented- so sad she has departed this world. She was such a talented, accomplished actress, not to mention so pretty. I always wondered why she stopped doing television- I think in 1979 and started doing theater/plays.

              I know she was big on drama/acting in high school but I always wondered about this.
              I thank you all for reading my post, Iva if you read this I did another post- if you can read it and if you like to check out the pages I did on Patricia. Apologies for imposing- currently working on a Wiki page on her.

              Best regards to all, thank you so much, ColumboPhile, thank you Iva,

              Ed from Miami, FL

  10. As a Columbo fan and vintage telephone collector this one is an interesting episode as it is one of many to feature the Bell System’s (the US phone monopoly at the time) latest wares, in this case the WE (Western Electric) Card Dialler, a short lived automatic dialling telephone. The answer machine is an early model made by Dictaphone using 8 track technology. Bell System phones are common props in columbo, a tampered with WE 2500 multi line phone in “Excercise in Fatality”, a WE Automatic Telephone in “Old Fashioned Murder” and of course the wall mounted WE 2554 in “How to Dial a Murder”. I always wondered if the Bell System advertised in the ad breaks as a commercial tie in.

  11. I’m a big fan of ransom. Mainly because I’m convinced Columbo has an idea what’s going on before he even arrives.
    When he enters the house and is introduced as local police liaison he announces that they have found the car. Although the FBI are already aware of this Columbo later claims that the drivers seat was too close and he couldn’t find the car keys. This made him believe a woman was driving the car and explains his entrance when he gets the wife to help him look for his pen. Surely she wouldn’t care less about his pen if she was genuinely worried about her husband.
    Columbo had solved this case before he even appeared on screen. Legend

  12. I’ve always thought the writers missed a great clue in “Ransom for a Dead Man.” A great negative clue. When the FBI and Columbo arrive at the drop location and find the empty flight bag, no one treats it as evidence. After all, the bag could have the “kidnapper’s” fingerprints on it. It should have been handled with care, sealed in plastic, etc. Even if Columbo often isn’t very by-the-book with evidence, the FBI always is. And the bag should have been fingerprinted. This would have revealed no prints (as Leslie was wearing gloves when she tossed it from the plane). But how is this possible? Lots of people handled that bag, loading the money, etc. They weren’t wearing gloves. The absence of their prints would have been powerful evidence that this wasn’t the bag the FBI filled with the ransom money.

  13. Mrs Williams wasn’t bad looking either but I’m not a huge fan of ransom for a dead man, I prefer the other pilot prescription murder as I think it has more memorable scenes better script and storyline and better clues and ending but I am not condemning Ransom for a dead man its a good episode.

  14. i love the scene as kay freestone races back to the projection booth in make me a perfect murder its the best scene from the entire 70s and what a strong episode it was and a gorgeous Colombo killer.

  15. Pingback: Season 4: have we reached ‘peak Columbo’? | The Columbophile

  16. Pingback: Episode review: Columbo A Deadly State of Mind | The Columbophile

  17. Pingback: Episode review: Columbo Playback | The Columbophile

  18. Pingback: Episode review: Columbo Troubled Waters | The Columbophile

Leave a Reply to Ed Porben Cancel reply